Started as an allocation pass over `StepCache` and grew into a cleanup of the surrounding pathing engine. Four commits, each independently reviewable; net **−560 lines**.
Build clean (0 warnings). All 122 `Server.Tests.Pathfinding` tests pass.
---
## 1. `perf`: pool the strata buffer, cut a hot-path dictionary lookup
**The headline is that `TryGetMask` — the actual hot path — was already allocation-free.** `StepMask` is a readonly struct, `StaticTileEnumerable` is a `ref struct`, `ChunkMissState` is a struct in a `Dictionary`. So most of this is a bake-throughput and GC-churn win, with one exception noted below.
`BuildChunk` accumulated packed multi-Z strata into a `List<byte>` that grew by doubling (256 → 512 → 1024 → …) and then paid a final `ToArray()`. A full map bake runs it ~114k times. It now writes into a `byte[]` rented from `STArrayPool<byte>.Shared` through a span writer, and hands the chunk one exact-size copy.
**This required fixing a latent out-of-bounds guard.** The record-fit check reserved headroom for **8** strata (`StratumByteLength * 8`) while `ComputeStandableSurfaceZs` can return up to **16** — so a cell could write 305 bytes starting from a 65,383-byte offset. Against a `List` that was benign (it just grew past 64 KB, and emitted offsets stayed under the `NoStrata` sentinel). Against a fixed-size rented buffer it is an out-of-bounds write, so tightening it was a *prerequisite* for the pooling, not a drive-by. The guard is now exact, which additionally proves no emitted offset can collide with `NoStrata == ushort.MaxValue`.
**One genuine query-path win:** `ShouldPromoteAfterMiss` did *two* dictionary lookups per miss — a `TryGetValue`, then an indexer assignment that re-hashes and re-probes. It now mutates in place via `CollectionsMarshal.GetValueRefOrNullRef`. This runs on every uncached chunk touch during A* expansion. The window-expiry branch keeps its explicit early return, so `MissPromotionThreshold == 1` still resets rather than promoting.
Also dropped `StepProbe.ComputeStrataAt` / `ComputedStratum` (dead code, zero callers) and collapsed six 18-argument `new StepMask(0, 0, …, kind)` blocks into `Fallthrough(kind)`.
**Considered and rejected:** pooling the `Direction[]` that `Find` returns. It *escapes* the call — `MovementPath` holds it across ticks while `PathFollower` walks `m_Index` through it — so it cannot be rented-and-returned, and it cannot be borrowed from the shared `BitmapAStarAlgorithm.Instance` without one creature clobbering another's in-flight path. `CheckPath` rate-limits repaths to one per 2s per creature, putting this at roughly 60 KB/sec at 1,000 pathing creatures. Not worth a public API break plus a use-after-return footgun.
## 2. `docs`: rewrite the comments for publication
The comments had accumulated as development notes: internal phase jargon (`Tier 4`, `the Phase-2 synthesizer`), change narration aimed at a reviewer (`which the old ComputeStandingZ anchor missed`, `legacy behavior`), benchmark anecdotes (`benchmarked as near-optimal`, `a ~20 ns lookup`), and paragraphs restating the code.
Rewritten to keep the rationale you cannot recover by reading the code — why the source-Z guard cannot be widened, why multis fall through with a halo, why the promotion gate counts Finds rather than calls, why `ComputeFingerprint` must hash the *files* and not the live tile tables — and drop the history that got us there.
Three comments were **factually wrong**, not just wordy:
- `CacheEvictionTimer` and `CacheStats` documented a class called `StaticWalkabilityCache`. No such class exists — it is `StepCache`.
- `StepCacheFile` declared `File layout v8` while `FormatVersion` is 9, and called the current record layout "the v6 layout" in four places. The layout descriptions are now unversioned so they cannot drift again.
- `StepProbe.ComputeStandingZ` claimed `StepCache` uses it to bake `SourceZ`. It has not since the baker moved to the clearance-aware `ComputeStandableSurfaceZs`; only a parity test calls it.
## 3. `refactor`: simplify `StepCacheFile.Write`, consolidate the format tests
`SaveToFile` walked `_keysList` **twice** — once to count the map's chunks, then again through a `ChunkEnumerator` closure to emit them — because `Write` needed the count up front to size its index array. Both loops had the same root cause. Passing a **span** collapses them: the count is just `span.Length`.
That deletes the `ChunkEnumerator` delegate, the closure over the list enumerator, and **both `InvalidOperationException` throws**, which existed only to police the delegate's "yield exactly `chunkCount` chunks" contract — a contract a span makes unrepresentable.
`Write` now patches the header's `IndexOffset` by seeking back to it rather than reaching into the writer's live buffer with `BinaryPrimitives`. That also retires `IndexOffsetFieldPosition`, a hand-maintained byte offset that had to track the header layout, and sidesteps the stale-array hazard that motivated the manual patch (`BufferWriter` reallocates on growth).
**Tests:** `StepCacheFileV6/V7/V8Tests` were named for the format version that introduced each transform — and the format is now **v9**, so all three names described formats the loader rejects outright. Beyond triplicated builders and plumbing, two things were actually broken:
- The three near-identical rejection tests each cited a `MinSupportedVersion` that had since moved (`"version 5 < MinSupportedVersion 6"`, `"6 < 7"`, `"7 < 8"`). They passed for the wrong reason.
- `AssertBaseEqual` (used by V7 and V8) **silently skipped the swim and strata trailers**. A regression dropping either would not have failed those tests.
Now one `StepCacheFileFormatTests`, named for behavior — predictive-Z elision, compression, compact index — with a single `AssertIdentical` that does check both trailers, the three rejection tests folded into one theory that also covers a future version, and a zero-chunk case the delegate-based writer never had coverage for.
## 4. `test`: consolidate the parity and lifecycle tests
Three files tested "parity" and none of the names said *which*. They were three different layers, and the seams are the useful part, so they are now one `StepCacheParityTests` that names them:
| Test | Compares | Answers |
|---|---|---|
| `ProbeMatchesSlowPath` | StepProbe vs MovementImpl | Is the bake right? |
| `CacheMatchesProbe` | StepCache vs StepProbe | Is it stored and returned intact? |
| `CacheServesReachableWalkStates` | StepCache vs MovementImpl | End to end, over the states A* visits |
Merging removed a duplicated stub `Mobile`, duplicated region seeds, and a filename/class mismatch (`StepProbeParityTests.cs` declared `StaticWalkabilityParityTests`). `SwimBake_ProducesWetCells` moved with it — it lived in the cache parity file but never touched the cache.
Tests reached into `StepCache._chunks` via `GetField` in **9 places**, each rebuilding the key encoding and cell-index arithmetic by hand. `StepCache` now exposes `GetResidentChunk` and `ResidentIndexInSync` alongside the internal test hooks it already had (`LazyReaderHasChunk`, `CurrentFindGeneration`), and the shared arithmetic moved to `PathingTestSupport`. All 9 reflection blocks are gone.
`StepCacheLifecycleTests` is regrouped by what it covers — promotion gate, fallthrough routes, strata, swim layer, eviction — with the `Tier4*` names dropped. Removed `Singleton_IsAvailable`, which asserted an inline-initialized static property was not null; that is the entire 123 → 122 test-count delta.
---
## Verification
Tests were mutation-checked rather than just run, since round-trip and parity tests can pass while a transform silently no-ops:
- Injecting an off-by-one into the `IndexOffset` patch fails **15 of 123** — the format tests are load-bearing.
- Offsetting the cache's cell index by one fails **7 of 10** parity cases, and the 3 that stay green are exactly the ones that do not touch the cache. The layering localizes a fault rather than just reporting one.
## Summary
Fixes the pathfinding step-cache (`.swb`) prebake so it bakes **once** and skips when a valid cache already exists, instead of re-baking on every boot. The root cause was the staleness fingerprint hashing mutable in-memory tile data rather than the on-disk files. This PR makes the fingerprint a pure function of the client data files and separates dynamic multis (houses/boats) from the static cache.
> This branch builds on the `ConfigurePrompts` first-boot-prompt unification (commit `5df8d0bd`, also included here) — that commit accounts for the `ServerConfiguration.cs` and `dev-docs/server-lifecycle.md` changes in the diff.
## The bug
With `pathfinding.prebakeMaps` set, the cache re-baked on **every** boot. The `.swb` staleness fingerprint hashed the live `TileData.LandTable`/`ItemTable` flags, which the server patches at runtime (`ItemFixes`, `LOSBlocker`, `PotionKeg`, `CTF`) at nondeterministic lifecycle points (Initialize-phase methods share a priority; static ctors fire lazily). So a fingerprint stamped at runtime (`[PathBake`) never matched the one recomputed during startup `Initialize()`, and the cache rebaked every time.
## Changes
**1. Fingerprint the files, not the in-memory tables** (`fix`)
Hash `tiledata.mul` (cached, computed once) plus the per-map `.mul`/`.uop` files — never the runtime-mutated `TileData` tables. The fingerprint is now lifecycle-stable. Existing `.swb` files rebake once after deploy, then stay stable.
**2. Compute the fingerprint once per boot** (`refactor`)
`Configure()`'s `AutoLoadAtStartup()` already opens and fingerprint-validates a reader for every up-to-date `.swb`. `Initialize()` now skips baking any map that already has an open reader (`StepCache.HasLazyReader`) instead of recomputing the fingerprint a second time.
**3. Bake static-only; route multis to the live path** (`refactor`)
Multis (houses/boats) are dynamic, so they're no longer baked into the static chunk cache — they were tagged with `BuiltMultisVersion`, a non-persisted session counter, which made persisting them unsafe (false matches / wasted re-bakes).
- Chunks bake land + `statics.mul` only.
- At query time, any cell whose sector (or its 1-cell halo) contains a multi routes to `Fallthrough_Multi` → the existing live, multi-aware `CheckMovement` path. The halo prevents a cell proposing a walkable edge into a neighbouring wall; interior (multi-free) cells pay one sector lookup.
- Adds `Sector.HasMultis` (one engine accessor); `.swb` format → v9 (rejects old multi-baked files); new `Fallthrough_Multi` telemetry.
- Behaviour-preserving: multis use the same live path the engine used before the cache existed.
**4. Comment polish** (`style`) — no behaviour change.
## Testing
All green: **92** pathfinding (incl. a new fingerprint-stability test and a multi-halo fallthrough test), **423** UOContent, **708** Server.
## Follow-ups (not in this PR)
- **Background bake worker** — make `[PathBake` and the boot prebake non-blocking (game thread serves tile reads to an off-thread worker).
- **Per-multi MCL cache** — cache walkability in each multi's own frame (keyed by multiID, movement-invariant) so houses/boats get a fast path instead of the live fallback.
- **House-pathfinding equivalence tests** — the one area not yet covered by a dedicated automated test; multi pathing is currently correct by delegation to the live path.
## Summary
Closes the Cold-cache regression flagged in PR #2450. `StepCache.TryGetMask` no longer eagerly runs `BuildChunk` on the first miss for a chunk that isn't in a `.swb` lazy reader. Instead it returns `Fallthrough_NotBuilt` and the caller (`BitmapAStarAlgorithm`) takes the per-cell slow path. The chunk is only promoted to the bitmap fast path after the **second** miss within a 30-second window, filtering single-touch pass-throughs.
This makes BitmapAStar's worst-case (cold cache + short hops) collapse from **12–47× slower** than FastAStar to **roughly the same**, which is the floor the slow path can deliver. Steady-state warm performance (the actual deliverable) is unchanged from PR-5 — it was always the cache fast path.
## The pet-follow scenario this fixes
A mounted player at ~4 tiles/sec with a pet/hireable following will trigger an NPC pathfind every 100–300 ms. Each pathfind is 1–6 tiles. As the player crosses chunk boundaries (~4 sec/chunk), the pet's first pathfind in the new chunk under the previous behavior triggered a full ~700 µs `BuildChunk` for a chunk the player would leave shortly after. At 50–100 mobiles per shard, this exceeded the 8 ms tick budget. PR-5 BDN data showed scenarios 6–9 (2–8 tile NPC perception) at 2,300–3,700 µs Cold vs FastAStar's 80–200 µs.
Under the new gate:
- First miss → `Fallthrough_NotBuilt` → caller uses slow path (~30–50 µs short path). No `BuildChunk`. No allocation.
- Player keeps moving → chunk never gets a second touch within window → never promoted, no rot.
- NPC patrolling a fixed territory → repeatedly hits the same chunks → second touch within window → promote → cache fast path on subsequent calls.
## What changed
- **`CacheHitKind.Fallthrough_NotBuilt = 6`** + **`CacheStats.FallthroughNotBuilt`** counter. `IsHit=false`, so the caller routes to slow path.
- **`StepCache._chunkMissTracker`** — `Dictionary<long, ChunkMissState>` capped at 4096 entries. State is `(byte missCount, uint lastMissTickStamp)` keyed by chunk key. Window-expired entries reset count to 1; capacity overflow prunes window-old entries first.
- **`StepCache.MissPromotionThreshold`** (default `2`) and **`StepCache.MissPromotionWindowMs`** (default `30_000`) — tunable, can be wired through `ServerConfiguration` if shards want different policy. Setting threshold to `1` restores legacy eager-build behavior (used by tests that prime chunks via single `TryGetMask` call).
- **`StepCache.TryGetMask` miss branch** — try lazy reader first (file-loaded chunks bypass the tracker entirely; an `.swb` represents an explicit prior decision to keep the chunk warm). Otherwise consult the tracker.
- **`BitmapAStarAlgorithm.GetSuccessorsSlowPath`** now layers `IsBlockedByDynamic` on top of `CalcMoves.CheckMovement`. Previously the slow path only ran for `CanFly` creatures and rare cache fallthroughs — `CheckMovement` doesn't iterate same-cell mobiles, so the bitmap fast path's `IsBlockedByDynamic` was the only mobile-blocking check. Now first-touch pathfinds run through the slow path, so the gap had to close.
## Tests
50 pathfinding tests pass (was 47). New / updated:
- **`TryGetMask_FirstTouchOnUnbuiltChunk_DefersBuildAndReturnsFallthrough`** — single TryGetMask call returns `Fallthrough_NotBuilt`, no chunk built, no allocation.
- **`TryGetMask_SecondTouchWithinWindow_PromotesAndBuilds`** — second call inside the 30s window builds + serves.
- **`TryGetMask_SecondTouchAfterWindow_RestartsCounterAndDefers`** — second call outside the window restarts the count, returns Fallthrough again.
- **`TryGetMask_DistinctChunks_TrackedIndependently`** — counters are per-chunk; one touch on each of two adjacent chunks both stay in fallthrough.
- **`LazyReaderHit_BypassesMissTrackerOnFirstTouch`** — open `.swb` + first touch hits without consulting the tracker. Production with `.swb` loaded skips the gate entirely.
- **`MultisVersion_Bump_TriggersDirtyRebuild`** — updated to reflect the new 3-step flow (Fallthrough → Miss_NotBuilt → Miss_DirtyRebuild).
- Tests that prime chunks via a single `TryGetMask` call (multi-Z, Tier4, lifecycle, parity, BitmapAStar uses-cache) set `MissPromotionThreshold = 1` to opt into eager behavior.
## Expected BDN impact
The Cold column from PR-5's BDN should change as follows once the bench's submodule pointer is updated to this branch:
| # | Scenario | Cold (PR-5) | Cold (PR-6 expected) | FastAStar Cold |
|--:|-----------------|-------------:|---------------------:|---------------:|
| 2 | sewer corridor | 1,627 µs | ~36 µs | 36 µs |
| 4 | causeway | 1,533 µs | ~39 µs | 39 µs |
| 6 | pet 2-tile | 2,364 µs | ~80 µs | 81 µs |
| 8 | npc 5-tile | 3,708 µs | ~140 µs | 141 µs |
| 9 | npc 8-tile | 2,386 µs | ~200 µs | 197 µs |
WarmNoFile and LazyWarm rows should be unchanged — they were always cache-warm. The miss tracker only fires when neither resident chunks nor the lazy reader can satisfy the request.
## Future work (not in this PR)
- **Background-thread bake**: builds outside the game thread so even promoted chunks don't pay the 700 µs build cost on the main thread. Rule 10 (no Task.Run) applies, so this needs careful design — the bake is a pure data transform but main-thread synchronization on chunk-state transitions has to be threaded through. Defer to a follow-up.
- **Long-traverse BDN scenario**: a multi-Find benchmark simulating 50 pet repaths across chunk transitions. Requires restructuring the bench harness; the existing 10-scenario corpus + Cold provider already exercises the gate.
- **Swim sourceZ bake**: scenario 5 (sea serpent) shows 56 B alloc on warm paths because the cache's SourceZ is computed under default-walker rules. Swim creatures fall through to slow path. Independent of this PR.
## Summary
Builds on PR #2446's cache-direct A*. The previous PR conservatively routed players + creatures with capability flags entirely through the slow path. This PR pushes that line: most mobile classes now use the cache, with the right rule set layered on top per-mobile, and the cache fast-path now does the dynamic items / mobiles check that PR #2446 had silently skipped.
## What changed
- **Non-GM players** now use the cache. Diagonal corner-cut applies the strict AND-rule (BOTH cardinal partners walkable) by reading the same source-cell mask byte the creature OR-rule reads — both rules are evaluable from one byte.
- **Creatures with `CanOpenDoors` / `CanMoveOverObstacles`** now use the cache. Reading `MovementImpl` confirmed those flags only affect dynamic items, never static tiles, so they were over-conservatively excluded before.
- **Swim creatures** now use the cache via a capability overlay. `StepProbe` bakes a second rule set (`canSwim=true, cantWalk=true`) producing `WetMask` + `SwimZ_*`. The algorithm composes `effectiveMask = (walkMask & !cantWalk) | (wetMask & canSwim)` per direction; walk Z preferred when both apply.
- **Dynamic-obstacle pass.** Cache fast-path now mirrors `MovementImpl`'s per-cell items + mobiles collision check (`GetItemsAt` / `GetMobilesAt` at the target cell, with `CanOpenDoors` / `CanMoveOverObstacles` / spell-field overrides). This closes a correctness gap from PR #2446 — the cache fast-path was silently skipping dynamic obstacles entirely.
- **`StepCache.TryGetMask` returns `StepMask` struct** instead of 11 out parameters. `HitKind` rolls into the struct with an `IsHit` accessor. Sets up wet/swim without ballooning the call site.
- **`StepChunk.MultiZCells` is lazy-init.** Most chunks are entirely single-Z; allocating the 32-byte bitmap up-front wasted ~256KB at full cap.
- **Admin commands.** `[PathCacheStats` (resident chunks + hit/miss/eviction counters) and `[PathCacheClear` (drop everything, zero counters).
- **Feature flag.** `bitmap_pathfinding_cache` (default true) gates the cache fast-path. Flipped off, every cell expansion routes to `MovementImpl` — equivalent to PR #2446's slow-path-only behavior. Safety net for shipping the new behavior.
`RequiresSlowPath` shrinks to just `CanFly` — flying creatures Z-jump arbitrarily, which the cache's static-Z model can't accommodate.
## Summary
Replaces `FastAStarAlgorithm` with `BitmapAStarAlgorithm`: one cache lookup per cell expansion (8-direction mask + per-direction destination Z) instead of 8 separate `MovementImpl.CheckMovement` calls. Adds the supporting cache infrastructure to back it.
Public API unchanged — `MovementPath` / `Mobile.Move` / `CalcMoves.Find` return the same shapes; the algorithm swap is internal.
## What's in this PR
- **`BitmapAStarAlgorithm`** — A* that issues one `StepCache.TryGetMask` call per cell expansion. Inline fallthrough to the per-cell slow path for multi-Z, off-map, source-Z mismatch, and non-default walkers.
- **`StepCache`** — singleton chunk store keyed by `(mapId, chunkX, chunkY)`. Lazily built on first query, invalidated by `Sector.MultisVersion` mismatch, memory-bounded by sampled probabilistic LRU.
- **`StepProbe`** — computes static-only walkability for a single cell, mirroring `MovementImpl.Check` minus the item / mobile collision phases.
- **`StepMask` / `StepChunk`** — value / storage types for the per-cell results.
- **`CacheEvictionTimer`** — periodic cap backstop (60s interval; early-returns when not over cap).
- **`Map.Sector.MultisVersion`** promoted to `public` so the cache can detect dynamic-static invalidations cheaply.
## Eviction strategy
Sampled probabilistic LRU (Redis-style). Per eviction, sample 5 random keys from a parallel `List<long>` kept in lockstep with the chunk dictionary; evict the oldest of the sample via swap-and-pop. O(1) per eviction regardless of resident count, so sustained cap pressure has no perpetual perf hit.
## Capability handling (interim)
Non-default walkers (non-GM players, creatures with `CanSwim` / `CanFly` / `CanOpenDoors` / `CanMoveOverObstacles`) route entirely through the per-cell slow path via `BitmapAStarAlgorithm.GetSuccessorsSlowPath`. The 2-pass design (cache + capability overlay + dynamic-obstacle pass) lands in the follow-up PR.
Kamron Batman