The pathing and step-cache comments had accumulated as development notes rather
than documentation: internal phase jargon ("Tier 4", "the Phase-2 synthesizer"),
change narration aimed at a reviewer ("which the old ComputeStandingZ anchor
missed", "legacy behavior"), benchmark anecdotes ("benchmarked as near-optimal",
"a ~20 ns lookup"), and multi-paragraph blocks restating what the code says.
Rewritten to keep the rationale a reader cannot derive from the code - why the
source-Z guard cannot be loosened, why multis fall through, why the promotion gate
counts Finds instead of calls, why the fingerprint hashes files rather than the
live tile tables - and to drop the history that got us there.
Also corrects comments that had gone stale:
- CacheEvictionTimer and CacheStats documented a class named
StaticWalkabilityCache, which no longer exists; it is StepCache.
- StepCacheFile's header said "File layout v8" while FormatVersion is 9, and the
body called the current record layout "the v6 layout" throughout. The layout
descriptions are now unversioned, since they describe whatever FormatVersion
currently is.
- StepProbe.ComputeStandingZ claimed StepCache uses it to bake SourceZ. It hasn't
since the baker moved to the clearance-aware ComputeStandableSurfaceZs; only a
parity test calls it now.
Two small code changes came along with the comment work, both behavior-preserving:
_lazyReaders now uses a collection expression like its neighbours, and
TryLoadFromLazyReader collapses to an expression body once its inline comment moved
to the doc comment.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
## Problem
Houses and boats (multis) were pathed correctly only by **delegation to the slow path**: `StepCache.TryGetMask` returns `Fallthrough_Multi` for any multi-covered cell, and `GetSuccessors` ran `CheckMovement` **8× per cell** (each re-resolving the tile stack via `GetStaticAndMultiTiles`) — a sustained per-step cost near every house/boat. There was also no automated test pinning multi pathfinding.
This branch is the full multi-pathfinding effort in phases on one branch.
## Phase 1 — characterization tests (the oracle)
Implementation-agnostic invariants: a cache-on≡cache-off whole-path invariant, a per-cell sweep vs `CheckMovement` over footprint+halo (incl. destination Z), hand-verified routing (around walls, demolish-reopens, foundation-redesign-honored), classic-house / foundation / boat fixtures, non-vacuity guards. These gate every later phase byte-for-byte.
## Phase 2 — live single-pass synthesizer
`StepProbe.ComputeMultiMaskAt` synthesizes a covered cell's full 8-direction `StepMask` in one pass (the existing surface/step logic over `GetStaticAndMultiTiles` instead of 8× `CheckMovement`). `GetSuccessors` routes `Fallthrough_Multi` cells through it. No new cache, no `.swb` change. **~1.5×**, zero added allocations.
## Phase 3 / 3.1 — warm per-`multiID` interior cache (airtight)
`MultiMaskCache` caches each fixed multi's local-frame `StepMask` for **interior** cells (cell + all 8 neighbours covered → terrain-neighbour-free → position-invariant), keyed by `multiID & 0x3FFF`, built lazily from the MCL. Interior cells become ~20 ns lookups.
The cache is gated on a **per-instance footprint-clean flag** (`BaseMulti.PathInteriorCacheState`): an instance whose whole footprint terrain is below its floor (`maxTerrain < minFloor`) serves from the cache; a **dirty** instance (terrain intrudes — a contrived/GM placement) **degrades to live-synth, never a wrong mask**. This closes a cross-instance soundness gap (the cached mask depends on neighbour terrain too) found in a holistic review. The gate resets whenever the footprint's world-terrain relationship can change — **location, map, or ItemID** (a boat's heading swaps the MCL).
**Boats are cached too.** Their per-`multiID` deck masks are movement-invariant (built once per heading), so a sailing boat never rebuilds them; only the cheap clean-flag rescan repeats per move (and only when pathed near). Narrow existing boats have little interior; wide galleons (`multi.mul`) would gain Castle-class. `HouseFoundation` (per-instance runtime `DesignState`) is the one type that stays on the live path.
## Verification
- `UOContent.Tests` **454/454**, `Server.Tests` **708/708**, 0 failures.
- The Phase-1 oracle (`MultiPathInvariantTests`, cache-on ≡ cache-off) stays **byte-identical** with the synthesizer + interior cache active.
- Tests pin: footprint-cleanliness (clean vs sunk), dirty/cluttered placement degrades to live-synth while still pathing, clean placement serves, and the gate resets on move/ItemID change.
## Performance (modernuo/ModernUO-Benchmarks#8, full-fixture)
Houses at **Green Acres** (flat staff region → clean footprints, the legit-placement case):
| Route | Slow path | Phase 3.1 (interior cache) | Speedup |
|-------|----------:|---------------------------:|--------:|
| `around_a` (29 steps) | 238.3 µs | **49.1 µs** | **4.85×** |
| `around_b` (29 steps) | 224.3 µs | **49.5 µs** | **4.53×** |
~130 of ~167 multi cells/route serve from the cache (~20 ns) vs 37 live-synth. Per-cell, the slow path's 8× `CheckMovement` grows with multi complexity (GuildHouse ~857 ns → Castle ~1,194 ns), the synthesizer is a flat ~780 ns, and the cache serve is ~20 ns — so big/tall multis (and wide galleons) gain most. Identical allocations throughout.
## Summary
Fixes the pathfinding step-cache (`.swb`) prebake so it bakes **once** and skips when a valid cache already exists, instead of re-baking on every boot. The root cause was the staleness fingerprint hashing mutable in-memory tile data rather than the on-disk files. This PR makes the fingerprint a pure function of the client data files and separates dynamic multis (houses/boats) from the static cache.
> This branch builds on the `ConfigurePrompts` first-boot-prompt unification (commit `5df8d0bd`, also included here) — that commit accounts for the `ServerConfiguration.cs` and `dev-docs/server-lifecycle.md` changes in the diff.
## The bug
With `pathfinding.prebakeMaps` set, the cache re-baked on **every** boot. The `.swb` staleness fingerprint hashed the live `TileData.LandTable`/`ItemTable` flags, which the server patches at runtime (`ItemFixes`, `LOSBlocker`, `PotionKeg`, `CTF`) at nondeterministic lifecycle points (Initialize-phase methods share a priority; static ctors fire lazily). So a fingerprint stamped at runtime (`[PathBake`) never matched the one recomputed during startup `Initialize()`, and the cache rebaked every time.
## Changes
**1. Fingerprint the files, not the in-memory tables** (`fix`)
Hash `tiledata.mul` (cached, computed once) plus the per-map `.mul`/`.uop` files — never the runtime-mutated `TileData` tables. The fingerprint is now lifecycle-stable. Existing `.swb` files rebake once after deploy, then stay stable.
**2. Compute the fingerprint once per boot** (`refactor`)
`Configure()`'s `AutoLoadAtStartup()` already opens and fingerprint-validates a reader for every up-to-date `.swb`. `Initialize()` now skips baking any map that already has an open reader (`StepCache.HasLazyReader`) instead of recomputing the fingerprint a second time.
**3. Bake static-only; route multis to the live path** (`refactor`)
Multis (houses/boats) are dynamic, so they're no longer baked into the static chunk cache — they were tagged with `BuiltMultisVersion`, a non-persisted session counter, which made persisting them unsafe (false matches / wasted re-bakes).
- Chunks bake land + `statics.mul` only.
- At query time, any cell whose sector (or its 1-cell halo) contains a multi routes to `Fallthrough_Multi` → the existing live, multi-aware `CheckMovement` path. The halo prevents a cell proposing a walkable edge into a neighbouring wall; interior (multi-free) cells pay one sector lookup.
- Adds `Sector.HasMultis` (one engine accessor); `.swb` format → v9 (rejects old multi-baked files); new `Fallthrough_Multi` telemetry.
- Behaviour-preserving: multis use the same live path the engine used before the cache existed.
**4. Comment polish** (`style`) — no behaviour change.
## Testing
All green: **92** pathfinding (incl. a new fingerprint-stability test and a multi-halo fallthrough test), **423** UOContent, **708** Server.
## Follow-ups (not in this PR)
- **Background bake worker** — make `[PathBake` and the boot prebake non-blocking (game thread serves tile reads to an off-thread worker).
- **Per-multi MCL cache** — cache walkability in each multi's own frame (keyed by multiID, movement-invariant) so houses/boats get a fast path instead of the live fallback.
- **House-pathfinding equivalence tests** — the one area not yet covered by a dedicated automated test; multi pathing is currently correct by delegation to the live path.
## Summary
Closes the Cold-cache regression flagged in PR #2450. `StepCache.TryGetMask` no longer eagerly runs `BuildChunk` on the first miss for a chunk that isn't in a `.swb` lazy reader. Instead it returns `Fallthrough_NotBuilt` and the caller (`BitmapAStarAlgorithm`) takes the per-cell slow path. The chunk is only promoted to the bitmap fast path after the **second** miss within a 30-second window, filtering single-touch pass-throughs.
This makes BitmapAStar's worst-case (cold cache + short hops) collapse from **12–47× slower** than FastAStar to **roughly the same**, which is the floor the slow path can deliver. Steady-state warm performance (the actual deliverable) is unchanged from PR-5 — it was always the cache fast path.
## The pet-follow scenario this fixes
A mounted player at ~4 tiles/sec with a pet/hireable following will trigger an NPC pathfind every 100–300 ms. Each pathfind is 1–6 tiles. As the player crosses chunk boundaries (~4 sec/chunk), the pet's first pathfind in the new chunk under the previous behavior triggered a full ~700 µs `BuildChunk` for a chunk the player would leave shortly after. At 50–100 mobiles per shard, this exceeded the 8 ms tick budget. PR-5 BDN data showed scenarios 6–9 (2–8 tile NPC perception) at 2,300–3,700 µs Cold vs FastAStar's 80–200 µs.
Under the new gate:
- First miss → `Fallthrough_NotBuilt` → caller uses slow path (~30–50 µs short path). No `BuildChunk`. No allocation.
- Player keeps moving → chunk never gets a second touch within window → never promoted, no rot.
- NPC patrolling a fixed territory → repeatedly hits the same chunks → second touch within window → promote → cache fast path on subsequent calls.
## What changed
- **`CacheHitKind.Fallthrough_NotBuilt = 6`** + **`CacheStats.FallthroughNotBuilt`** counter. `IsHit=false`, so the caller routes to slow path.
- **`StepCache._chunkMissTracker`** — `Dictionary<long, ChunkMissState>` capped at 4096 entries. State is `(byte missCount, uint lastMissTickStamp)` keyed by chunk key. Window-expired entries reset count to 1; capacity overflow prunes window-old entries first.
- **`StepCache.MissPromotionThreshold`** (default `2`) and **`StepCache.MissPromotionWindowMs`** (default `30_000`) — tunable, can be wired through `ServerConfiguration` if shards want different policy. Setting threshold to `1` restores legacy eager-build behavior (used by tests that prime chunks via single `TryGetMask` call).
- **`StepCache.TryGetMask` miss branch** — try lazy reader first (file-loaded chunks bypass the tracker entirely; an `.swb` represents an explicit prior decision to keep the chunk warm). Otherwise consult the tracker.
- **`BitmapAStarAlgorithm.GetSuccessorsSlowPath`** now layers `IsBlockedByDynamic` on top of `CalcMoves.CheckMovement`. Previously the slow path only ran for `CanFly` creatures and rare cache fallthroughs — `CheckMovement` doesn't iterate same-cell mobiles, so the bitmap fast path's `IsBlockedByDynamic` was the only mobile-blocking check. Now first-touch pathfinds run through the slow path, so the gap had to close.
## Tests
50 pathfinding tests pass (was 47). New / updated:
- **`TryGetMask_FirstTouchOnUnbuiltChunk_DefersBuildAndReturnsFallthrough`** — single TryGetMask call returns `Fallthrough_NotBuilt`, no chunk built, no allocation.
- **`TryGetMask_SecondTouchWithinWindow_PromotesAndBuilds`** — second call inside the 30s window builds + serves.
- **`TryGetMask_SecondTouchAfterWindow_RestartsCounterAndDefers`** — second call outside the window restarts the count, returns Fallthrough again.
- **`TryGetMask_DistinctChunks_TrackedIndependently`** — counters are per-chunk; one touch on each of two adjacent chunks both stay in fallthrough.
- **`LazyReaderHit_BypassesMissTrackerOnFirstTouch`** — open `.swb` + first touch hits without consulting the tracker. Production with `.swb` loaded skips the gate entirely.
- **`MultisVersion_Bump_TriggersDirtyRebuild`** — updated to reflect the new 3-step flow (Fallthrough → Miss_NotBuilt → Miss_DirtyRebuild).
- Tests that prime chunks via a single `TryGetMask` call (multi-Z, Tier4, lifecycle, parity, BitmapAStar uses-cache) set `MissPromotionThreshold = 1` to opt into eager behavior.
## Expected BDN impact
The Cold column from PR-5's BDN should change as follows once the bench's submodule pointer is updated to this branch:
| # | Scenario | Cold (PR-5) | Cold (PR-6 expected) | FastAStar Cold |
|--:|-----------------|-------------:|---------------------:|---------------:|
| 2 | sewer corridor | 1,627 µs | ~36 µs | 36 µs |
| 4 | causeway | 1,533 µs | ~39 µs | 39 µs |
| 6 | pet 2-tile | 2,364 µs | ~80 µs | 81 µs |
| 8 | npc 5-tile | 3,708 µs | ~140 µs | 141 µs |
| 9 | npc 8-tile | 2,386 µs | ~200 µs | 197 µs |
WarmNoFile and LazyWarm rows should be unchanged — they were always cache-warm. The miss tracker only fires when neither resident chunks nor the lazy reader can satisfy the request.
## Future work (not in this PR)
- **Background-thread bake**: builds outside the game thread so even promoted chunks don't pay the 700 µs build cost on the main thread. Rule 10 (no Task.Run) applies, so this needs careful design — the bake is a pure data transform but main-thread synchronization on chunk-state transitions has to be threaded through. Defer to a follow-up.
- **Long-traverse BDN scenario**: a multi-Find benchmark simulating 50 pet repaths across chunk transitions. Requires restructuring the bench harness; the existing 10-scenario corpus + Cold provider already exercises the gate.
- **Swim sourceZ bake**: scenario 5 (sea serpent) shows 56 B alloc on warm paths because the cache's SourceZ is computed under default-walker rules. Swim creatures fall through to slow path. Independent of this PR.
## Summary
Replaces `FastAStarAlgorithm` with `BitmapAStarAlgorithm`: one cache lookup per cell expansion (8-direction mask + per-direction destination Z) instead of 8 separate `MovementImpl.CheckMovement` calls. Adds the supporting cache infrastructure to back it.
Public API unchanged — `MovementPath` / `Mobile.Move` / `CalcMoves.Find` return the same shapes; the algorithm swap is internal.
## What's in this PR
- **`BitmapAStarAlgorithm`** — A* that issues one `StepCache.TryGetMask` call per cell expansion. Inline fallthrough to the per-cell slow path for multi-Z, off-map, source-Z mismatch, and non-default walkers.
- **`StepCache`** — singleton chunk store keyed by `(mapId, chunkX, chunkY)`. Lazily built on first query, invalidated by `Sector.MultisVersion` mismatch, memory-bounded by sampled probabilistic LRU.
- **`StepProbe`** — computes static-only walkability for a single cell, mirroring `MovementImpl.Check` minus the item / mobile collision phases.
- **`StepMask` / `StepChunk`** — value / storage types for the per-cell results.
- **`CacheEvictionTimer`** — periodic cap backstop (60s interval; early-returns when not over cap).
- **`Map.Sector.MultisVersion`** promoted to `public` so the cache can detect dynamic-static invalidations cheaply.
## Eviction strategy
Sampled probabilistic LRU (Redis-style). Per eviction, sample 5 random keys from a parallel `List<long>` kept in lockstep with the chunk dictionary; evict the oldest of the sample via swap-and-pop. O(1) per eviction regardless of resident count, so sustained cap pressure has no perpetual perf hit.
## Capability handling (interim)
Non-default walkers (non-GM players, creatures with `CanSwim` / `CanFly` / `CanOpenDoors` / `CanMoveOverObstacles`) route entirely through the per-cell slow path via `BitmapAStarAlgorithm.GetSuccessorsSlowPath`. The 2-pass design (cache + capability overlay + dynamic-obstacle pass) lands in the follow-up PR.
Kamron Batman