## Summary
About 114 tests skipped on CI because they needed the official client files (`tiledata.mul`, map and multi files). They gave CI no signal, and locally they ran against whichever client a developer had installed. The test hosts now build their own world instead, so every test runs on CI and runs the same on every machine. CI simulation: Server.Tests 837 passed, UOContent.Tests 1131 passed, **0 skipped**.
- **Generated tile data.** The fixtures write a pre-HS `tiledata.mul` from a small invented tile kit (`Server.Tests/Terrain/TestTiles`) and load it through the real `TileData.Load()`. The test hosts no longer read any client directory (`MODERNUO_CLIENT_PATH`, `MODERNUO_TEST_DATA_DIR` and `C:\Ultima Online Classic` are gone from test code). The file is written to `SyntheticData` in each test project's output, overwritten every run and removed by `dotnet clean`.
- **Injected terrain.** `TestTerrain` stamps land and statics into Felucca and Trammel, which share one terrain. Writes after startup must go in a `TestTerrain.Scope()`, which puts back every block it touched and keeps the step cache fresh.
- **Prefab scenes.** Seven named scenes (town, causeway, sewer walkway, coastline, deep sea, map-edge sea, an upstairs room with an L-shaped counter) replace the Britain coordinates the pathing, AI and fishing tests relied on. Each scene-based test asserts its scene is present first, so a missing scene fails instead of passing on flat ground. Stamping all seven takes 3-5 ms.
- **Multi footprints.** Contrived footprints for the three multi IDs content looks up (0x74, 0x7A, 0x0) are seeded through a new internal `MultiData.SetComponents`.
- **Fingerprint.** `StepCacheFile.HashTileDataFile` is extracted so a test can show that a one-flag change to the file changes the fingerprint, while runtime table mutation does not.
### Engine changes
- `TileMatrix.GetLandBlock`/`GetStaticBlock`: on a map without its files, return the block injected with `SetLandBlock`/`SetStaticBlock`, or the default when nothing was injected. Maps with files take the same path as before.
- `MultiData.SetComponents` (internal): registers a footprint without multi files.
### Test changes worth a look
- Values that were properties of real Britain terrain (probes at Z 10, a pinned plain walk mask of 0xC1) are re-pinned to the synthetic plain (Z 0, 0xFF).
- No tests were deleted. The multi walkability and boat-deck tests assert movement behaviour over a footprint, not what a real multi looks like, so they run on the contrived footprints.
- Maps 0 and 1 keep file indexes 0 and 1, and every stamp writes both, rather than sharing one file index. On a map without files the getters never consult the shared-file cache, and its patch bits would hide one facet's injection from the other.
## Test plan
- [x] `dotnet test -p:SolutionDir=... --filter "Category!=Manual"` with the client env vars pointed at an empty directory: 837 + 1131 passed, 0 skipped, 0 failed
- [x] Mutation check: removing the step-cache clear from `TestTerrain` makes the stale-cache tests fail
- [x] CI green on all platforms
## Summary
Many tests proved a specific change when it landed but don't need to run on every CI build forever. This removes **202 test methods and 9 files: 313 test cases, 2,247 → 1,934**. UOContent.Tests drops from about 14s to about 5s locally.
Removed:
- **Tautologies.** Asserting a constant, a constructor readback or a trivial getter, or testing BCL behavior.
- **Exact duplicates** of a surviving test on the same code path.
- **Obsolete regressions** whose failure can no longer be expressed.
- **Game-content values** shard owners customize (era drop rates, loot and skill tables, single-creature tuning). Each customization would otherwise force a test fix.
## How it was decided
1. Every test was classified, with a reason, by a per-shard sweep over all 287 test files.
2. Each proposed deletion was then checked by a second, adversarial reviewer against the surviving tests and the production code.
3. Anything that was the only coverage of a separate code path was **kept**, even where it looked like a duplicate. Examples: the unsigned `SpanReader`/`SpanWriter` methods, the at-location versus bounds enumerators, null-map enumerables, the security filters, archive-journal state transitions. About 130 proposed deletions were rejected this way.
Whole files removed:
- `FishingTests`, apart from 3 tests: the map-edge scan, serpent cleanup, and SOS chest consumption. The SOS test now stops at the first chest instead of measuring a catch rate. The multi-million-cast rate simulations are gone.
- `LordOaksTests` and `MeerEnragedTests` (single-creature tests).
- `AutoArchiveHelperTests`, `JsonDiscoverableTypeAttributeTests`, `DecimalSerializationTests` and `EnumConversionTests` (tautologies, or tests of their own local helpers).
- `NetworkStatsTests`.
- `MigratedDataLoadTests` (a subset of `AllSpawnFilesLoadTests`).
- `SpawnerFixtureCapture`: a capture tool, not a test, and its `version == 12` assert can no longer pass. The `.bin` fixtures it produced stay.
## Tests
- Server.Tests: 811 pass.
- UOContent.Tests: 1,123 pass.
A follow-up PR, stacked on this one, fixes how the remaining tests behave: shared state, CI-vacuous tests, harness duplication.
## Problem
Three coupled issues, each hiding the next:
1. **CI passed despite failing tests, with no test logs.** ([example run](https://github.com/modernuo/ModernUO/actions/runs/28639143286/job/84931544255) — the `Test` step produced zero output and the job went green.)
2. **Two `EmitsLowerStatReqWhenPassed` tests** fail with `KeyNotFoundException: '1060435'`.
3. Once CI actually ran the tests, **~337 UOContent tests failed** with `FileNotFoundException: tiledata.mul was not found` — the test bootstrap force-loaded copyrighted client data that CI doesn't have.
## Root causes & fixes
### 1. CI ran zero tests (`fix(ci)`)
The `Test` step ran `dotnet test --no-restore`, but the `Build` step only restores/builds `Application` — never the test projects. Without a restore, the test projects have no `project.assets.json`, so `Microsoft.NET.Test.Sdk`'s targets aren't imported, they aren't recognized as test projects, and `dotnet test` runs the `VSTest` target against **zero** projects → no output, **exit 0**.
- Both jobs now run `dotnet test --logger trx --results-directory ./TestResults` (test projects restore and run) **plus a guard** that fails the job if no `.trx` is produced — a permanent backstop against silent zero-test passes.
### 2. Impossible OPL tests (`fix(ci)` + `test(opl)`)
#2501 deliberately emits `LowerStatReq` (`1060435`) **inline in each item**, not in `GetProperties`. A follow-up "fix" dropped the `lowerStatReq:` argument to make the tests compile but left the assertions expecting `1060435`.
- Removed the two impossible tests, then removed the **entire `Tests/PropertyList/` OPL attribute set** from #2501: these assert exact cliloc/value/order of OPL emission per item base — a one-time proof of the #2501 rewire, now a permanent tax on modding (any admin reorder/value change/added line reddens the build). The one non-trivial case (LowerStatReq) is what just broke, because the test was wrong. Inline emission stays covered by the `BaseArmor`/`BaseClothing` tests.
### 3. Tile-data-dependent tests crashed CI (`test(uocontent)`)
UOContent.Tests' collection-fixture constructor force-loaded `tiledata.mul` unconditionally. On CI (no client files) it threw, and xUnit failed **every test in the collection** with the same error — mostly collateral (packet/scheduler/spawner tests that don't need tile data).
- Mirror Server.Tests' graceful pattern: `TestServerInitializer` probes for `tiledata.mul` and only loads tile/multi data (and runs the tile-dependent configure steps) when present, exposing `TileDataLoaded` so the fixture no longer throws.
- Add a shared `TileDataRequirement.SkipIfMissing()` guard and apply it to exactly the **31** pathfinding/multi/AI tests that genuinely need real tile data (`[SkippableFact]`/`[SkippableTheory]`).
## Verification (all local)
| Scenario | Server.Tests | UOContent.Tests |
|---|---|---|
| **Client data absent (CI)** | 726 pass, 17 skip, **0 fail** | 469 pass, 32 skip, **0 fail** |
| **Client data present (dev)** | 726 pass, 0 skip, **0 fail** | 501 pass, 0 skip, **0 fail** |
- Full `dotnet test` exits **0**; TRX files produced; the no-test guard trips (exit 1) only when zero `.trx` are produced.
## Problem
Houses and boats (multis) were pathed correctly only by **delegation to the slow path**: `StepCache.TryGetMask` returns `Fallthrough_Multi` for any multi-covered cell, and `GetSuccessors` ran `CheckMovement` **8× per cell** (each re-resolving the tile stack via `GetStaticAndMultiTiles`) — a sustained per-step cost near every house/boat. There was also no automated test pinning multi pathfinding.
This branch is the full multi-pathfinding effort in phases on one branch.
## Phase 1 — characterization tests (the oracle)
Implementation-agnostic invariants: a cache-on≡cache-off whole-path invariant, a per-cell sweep vs `CheckMovement` over footprint+halo (incl. destination Z), hand-verified routing (around walls, demolish-reopens, foundation-redesign-honored), classic-house / foundation / boat fixtures, non-vacuity guards. These gate every later phase byte-for-byte.
## Phase 2 — live single-pass synthesizer
`StepProbe.ComputeMultiMaskAt` synthesizes a covered cell's full 8-direction `StepMask` in one pass (the existing surface/step logic over `GetStaticAndMultiTiles` instead of 8× `CheckMovement`). `GetSuccessors` routes `Fallthrough_Multi` cells through it. No new cache, no `.swb` change. **~1.5×**, zero added allocations.
## Phase 3 / 3.1 — warm per-`multiID` interior cache (airtight)
`MultiMaskCache` caches each fixed multi's local-frame `StepMask` for **interior** cells (cell + all 8 neighbours covered → terrain-neighbour-free → position-invariant), keyed by `multiID & 0x3FFF`, built lazily from the MCL. Interior cells become ~20 ns lookups.
The cache is gated on a **per-instance footprint-clean flag** (`BaseMulti.PathInteriorCacheState`): an instance whose whole footprint terrain is below its floor (`maxTerrain < minFloor`) serves from the cache; a **dirty** instance (terrain intrudes — a contrived/GM placement) **degrades to live-synth, never a wrong mask**. This closes a cross-instance soundness gap (the cached mask depends on neighbour terrain too) found in a holistic review. The gate resets whenever the footprint's world-terrain relationship can change — **location, map, or ItemID** (a boat's heading swaps the MCL).
**Boats are cached too.** Their per-`multiID` deck masks are movement-invariant (built once per heading), so a sailing boat never rebuilds them; only the cheap clean-flag rescan repeats per move (and only when pathed near). Narrow existing boats have little interior; wide galleons (`multi.mul`) would gain Castle-class. `HouseFoundation` (per-instance runtime `DesignState`) is the one type that stays on the live path.
## Verification
- `UOContent.Tests` **454/454**, `Server.Tests` **708/708**, 0 failures.
- The Phase-1 oracle (`MultiPathInvariantTests`, cache-on ≡ cache-off) stays **byte-identical** with the synthesizer + interior cache active.
- Tests pin: footprint-cleanliness (clean vs sunk), dirty/cluttered placement degrades to live-synth while still pathing, clean placement serves, and the gate resets on move/ItemID change.
## Performance (modernuo/ModernUO-Benchmarks#8, full-fixture)
Houses at **Green Acres** (flat staff region → clean footprints, the legit-placement case):
| Route | Slow path | Phase 3.1 (interior cache) | Speedup |
|-------|----------:|---------------------------:|--------:|
| `around_a` (29 steps) | 238.3 µs | **49.1 µs** | **4.85×** |
| `around_b` (29 steps) | 224.3 µs | **49.5 µs** | **4.53×** |
~130 of ~167 multi cells/route serve from the cache (~20 ns) vs 37 live-synth. Per-cell, the slow path's 8× `CheckMovement` grows with multi complexity (GuildHouse ~857 ns → Castle ~1,194 ns), the synthesizer is a flat ~780 ns, and the cache serve is ~20 ns — so big/tall multis (and wide galleons) gain most. Identical allocations throughout.
Kamron Batman